Regulation

CMAL warns direct Ferguson Marine ferry award would be folly

Get the free FerryIntel Briefing, weekly on Monday or on the days that suit you.

The Herald reported on 18 November 2026 that CMAL chief executive Kevin Hobbs told MSPs he was 100% opposed to awarding the second phase of the Small Vessel Replacement Programme directly to Ferguson Marine. CMAL said the work should go to open competitive tender, called a direct award problematic at best and folly at worst, and said the two SVRP2 ferries are intended for the Sound of Harris and Sound of Barra.

Source: The Herald (opens in a new tab)

View on map

The Herald reported on 18 November 2026 that Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd (CMAL) has warned the Scottish Government against handing new vessel contracts directly to Ferguson Marine as part of a rescue deal, saying island communities need ferries delivered quickly and at a reasonable cost.

Chief executive Kevin Hobbs told MSPs he and the board do not believe the Port Glasgow yard is the right place to build the new ferries. Asked whether CMAL would prefer not to award the contracts to Ferguson Marine in the interests of islanders, the Herald reported he replied: “100 %”.

Ministers want to award Ferguson Marine contracts to build two more ferries under the second phase of the Small Vessel Replacement Programme (SVRP2), despite CMAL’s objections. The Herald said the two ferries are intended to serve the Sound of Harris and Sound of Barra routes.

In a written assessment of the proposed direct award, CMAL said the anticipated cost of designing, fabricating and delivering the vessels at Ferguson Marine “is likely to far outweigh the costs that could be achieved through an open, competitive procurement inviting bids from a range of capable and experienced shipbuilders in the market, both domestic and international, including from a range of different locations such as Turkey, Romania, Poland, and elsewhere”. The company also warned: “We cannot escape the risk of additional delays occurring once the project is underway at Ferguson's, such as as we have experienced in the completion of Glen Sannox and the still pending delivery of Glen Rosa.” CMAL added that the board “may reasonably consider that the proposed direct award is problematic at best and folly at worst”.

Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn defended the decision, saying in the Herald’s report: “The choice to build in Scotland is inescapably a political decision. I believe it is the right political decision”. Ferguson Marine chief executive Graeme Thomson said Glen Sannox is now in service with Glen Rosa due to follow shortly, and that today’s Ferguson Marine has new leadership, stronger governance, greater programme management control and a skilled workforce ready to deliver.

  1. CMAL takes delivery of MV Loch Indaal from Cemre

  2. Glen Rosa sets off on builder’s sea trials

  3. Flynn accepts a February 2027 handover for Glen Rosa

  4. CalMac profit falls as reliability drops

All items in Regulation